Saturday, January 27, 2007

NYT On BP "Minyan Factory"

NYT on Boro Park "minyan factory" Shomrei Shabbos:
At 10 o’clock on a recent Thursday night, the corner of 53rd Street and 13th Avenue in the heart of Borough Park was bustling with traffic. In this neighborhood, an ultra-Orthodox stronghold for the past decade, a sea of religious Jews clad in traditional black and white garb scurried in every direction for late-night prayer, shopping or something to eat. This corner of Brooklyn never sleeps, or so it seems.

The main attraction is Congregation Shomrei Shabbos, a 24-hour synagogue where a service begins every 15 minutes. What started more than three-quarters of a century ago as a tiny congregation has grown into a mainstay of this community: transit hub, soup kitchen, community center, bookstore and prayer hall all in one.

The late-night traffic generated by the synagogue has spilled onto the streets, so much so that over the past few years a neighborhood has literally grown up around it. Restaurants and stores are open long past midnight. Peddlers vie for street space in the wee hours. Religious music streams from a small boombox. Men stop their cars in the middle of darkened streets to announce the birth of a child.

...Thanks to all this activity, the once-inconspicuous synagogue is now a trigger for local nightlife.

“Real estate surrounding the synagogue is in high demand,” said Mendy Handler, owner of Cellular 4 Less, one of several local businesses that stay open past midnight to attract late-night synagogue-goers. His busiest hours are from 6 p.m. to midnight. “People can drop off their phones to be fixed while they are praying next door,” said Sol Oberlander, the store’s manager.

Other businesses have followed suit. Copy Corner stays open until midnight, as does Gal Paz, a music store. Sub Express, a kosher fast-food restaurant whose menu includes what is described as a unique “brisket egg roll,” keeps its doors open until 1 a.m.

Another popular outpost is Deli 52, which on Thursday nights serves two variations of cholent, a traditional Sabbath stew of beans, meat and barley, until 4 a.m. The late-night cholent attracts crowds of men, who often stay and schmooze until the morning hours, a somewhat controversial activity among the ultra-Orthodox, who pride themselves on not wasting time with idle chat.
Thursday night chulent makes the big time. Check it out.

27 comments:

  1. Anonymous1:29 AM

    I think its great, people, men in particular need a place to hang out, chill and release excess energy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous3:56 AM

    These minyan factories are common in BP. There's another one at the corner of New Utrecht and 54th. I davened Maariv there a few weeks ago. I'm not a black hatter so I was treated like a leper, even though I made it clear, in Yiddish, that I'm a chiyuv and in availos for my mother A"H. Moral-if you ain't one of them, you're lower than dirt.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous4:44 AM

    sorry about your experiance but chassidim are of the biggest ba'alei chessed and when a person is in need they usually do anything to help, most of the chessed orginizations from bikur cholima nd others were all started and are run by chassidim ur incident is an aberation. and no i m not chassidish please do not speak badly about any jew
    ps the shul u went to was probably shomer shabbas it is right of of new utrecht

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great article. The reporter did a good job capturing what actually is, as opposed to making Orthodox Jews seem like a group of anachronistic kooks.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have no doubt that these Chasidim do a lot of good - as long as you're one of them. If you don't look like them, you're dirt. I don't like to speak badly of other Jews but its true. There's a lot of Sinas Chinam under the chassideshe l'vush. I'm 42 years old and have been to BP hundreds of times. I went to Mirrer Yeshiva for HS and BM. I speak fluent Yiddish. My mother was an Auschwitz survivor. S'helft gurnisht - you don't wear black, you ain't worth jack.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous2:24 PM

    Can't wait till this happens here in the Five Towns!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Can women pray there? They can't at Landau's in Flatbush -- no Mechitzah.

    Personally, I've been nothing but welcomed in Chasidic minyanim -- in Manhattan, Riverdale, Flatbush, Montreal, and New Square -- despite the fact that I never wear a jacket and don't even own a black hat. Some local MO minyanim aren't as friendly.

    And I'd love to have a minyan factory near me -- the last maariv in my nbhd is at 9:30pm.

    ReplyDelete
  8. keithninety:

    i have my own sterotypes/prejudices re. bp, but i can't complain about chassidic shuls.

    my mother-in-law lives in bp. when i go there for shabbat i often daven in linden heights (10th ave), which is basically as modern as you can get in bp. i've never been given any kibud, not even just pesichah. no one has ever said hello to me.

    on the other hand, the few occasions that i've davened in chassidic shtieblch, they've always been friendly to me. most interesting is one particualr small basement bp shtiebel. for whatever reason they did not have a baal kore the shabbat i davened there. i told the rav that i can lein and he asked me if i would be willing to do it. this despite the fact that i was wearing a srugi, dockers and sweater (no tie, jacket, hat). i even warned him that i lein with havarah sefaradit and he was fine ("it's still the same torah," he responded). you could say that this was due to neccesity, but almost every time i've been back to that shtiebel since then they ask me to lein.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous1:10 AM

    here we go with these complexed people.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Ari:

    I'm pleased to hear about your good experiences in BP. Mine have not been as pleasant. I've been ignored, skipped over in line and basically been treated with contempt numerous times in BP. In fact, I've been treated better in Williamsburg than BP.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Anonymous8:09 AM

    The one thing I dont understand is that you can also get a scahrit minyan at 12:00pm???

    ReplyDelete
  12. Anonymous2:58 PM

    Minyan factory is okay if people join the shul. The White Shul is dying because people use it only as a minyan factory.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Anonymous3:04 PM

    We'd like to hear about the kid who "fell off' a balcony in MB

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anonymous7:07 PM

    Linden Heights is avery unique shul.It is the only shul that has a rabbi who is an ex-con.

    ReplyDelete
  15. never heard of linden heights... as far as i know the most "modern" shul in BP is Young Israel Beth El, on 15th avenue and 48th or so, near Bobov.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Anonymous3:33 PM

    The White Shul had tremendous wear and tear on their building and high electrical usage, while the people attending never even gave tzedakah to the shul. Why should the members of the White Shul support a community that disparages them while abusing their resources?

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous5:21 PM

    Charlie Hall 5:54 said:
    "Can women pray there? They can't at Landau's in Flatbush -- no Mechitzah."

    There is an upstairs section for ladies at Shomrei Shabbos. During the week, however, it's used as an extra mens section, with men learning or reciting tehillim there. The stairway from the outside is unlit (good thing I carry around a flashlight with me) and the door is sometimes locked, but I have davened mincha there on more than one occasion.

    Does Landaus never have a ladies section? Or is it just during the "off times" that the ladies section is unavailable?

    ReplyDelete
  18. steg:

    "never heard of linden heights... as far as i know the most "modern" shul in BP is Young Israel Beth El, on 15th avenue and 48th or so, near Bobov."

    it is on 9th and 45th. it is probably as "modern" as beth el is these days. it is pretty much a carpathian operation and would not ever recommend davening there on shabbat.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Anonymous12:30 AM

    The Landau's ladies section is upstairs and can be accessed from either entrance. During the week it is sometimes used for Maariv but on Shabbos it's a regular ladies section with a large opening to the main shul.

    ReplyDelete
  20. ari:

    for modernity, check out beth el's downstairs minyan (main entrance around the right side of the building), starts 8am on Shabbos.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Anonymous4:54 PM

    ITS NOT ONLY FOR PRAYERS
    ITS A PLACE WHERE PP CAN EAT DRINK
    AND BE COMFORTABLE ALL DAY LONG ,INCLUDING SHABATH MEALS
    YOU CAN SEE ALL TIME PP STOP TO DROP TRAYS OF CAKES BY THE SHUL
    MEE CEAMCHA ISRAEL
    I LOVE BORO PARK

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anonymous5:17 PM

    Thanks a lot for sharing thiѕ with all people you actually recognizе what you arе speaking
    аbout! Bookmаrked. Рlease additionally tаlκ over with my site =).
    We could have a hyρеrlink exchange cοntract between us rippln reviews - lindberg airport - rippln

    Here іs my pagе: rip apps from iphone to mac

    ReplyDelete