Powered by WebAds

Wednesday, July 12, 2006

A Tale of Two Cities

Funny to read about a city like Lakewood, NJ, where accusations are roiling that Orthodox students get better services than non-Orthodox students:
The town could face more problems, in the long run, from the recent findings of the New Jersey department of education. The department began investigating after the local American Civil Liberties Union issued a report indicating that Orthodox children were given a disproportionate number of referrals to expensive, out-of-district special education schools. The Lakewood School District filed a response from a former state commissioner of education arguing that the higher number of referrals was a result of the higher number of requests from the Orthodox community.

After an investigation, the state department of education called the town's response "disingenuous." The state found that white students were six times as likely to be given a full-day special education program than a non-white student, and that among children with the same disabilities, white students were systematically given more extensive help by the district.

"Program and placement decisions can be directly correlated with a student's race," the report concluded.
I find it funny because I live in a district where, in contrast, public school students receive services at a rate of three times of that of the district's mostly Orthodox private school students. Go figure.

22 Comments:

Anonymous mycroft said...

find it funny because I live in a district where, in contrast, public school students receive services at a rate of three times of that of the district's mostly Orthodox private school students

Ortho-what per cent of private schjool students would be eligivle for free or reduced school lunches

11:15 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

mycroft what does that have to do with the price of tea in lawrence?

11:22 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Go figure??? You like that phrase don't you? Ok, so let's talk about the REAL figures that were discussed in two articles in Newsday and the Herald (oh, I forgot, you don't believe anything the Herald prints). But first, the two issues in the two districts are completely different. In Lakewood, Orthodox students were recommended for out of district expensive private special education schools. What most likely happened there is that Orthodox (or in some other districts, "Orthodox" could be replaced by any other group...but the group most likely would be pretty well off, educated and for some,litigious parents)who happen to know about schools (or find attorneys who are aware of them). The group has the money to hire attorneys or if not, threaten to bring legal action against the district unless a certain school is recommended. This school most likely is only too happy to admit these students due to the hefty tuitions it receives from the districts, and probably has a student body that is mostly white and/or Orthodox which makes the parents want to send their child there even more since the student body is "acceptable". In District 15, ther is a very small percentage of students attending out of district private New York State approved special education schools. As far as your claim that 3 times as many public school students are recommended for special ed services than Orthodox students, the truth is this: 10% of all Orthodox students living in the district are recommended for special ed services....just where it should be compared to other districts who have students who come from similar socioeconomic situations as most Orthodox students do (socioeconomically) like Jericho, Garden City, Rockville Center, Scarsdale, (or even Ramapo),where LESS than 10% of the student body in those districts is recommended for special ed services. 15-17% of public school students who for the most part,come from a different socioeconomic status, are given special ed services. But do the math, that is hardly 3 times (10x 3 =30). It is irresponsible for you to make these inflammatory statements. Get your facts and figures straight before you print lies that only tend to get your readers riled up for no reason. Remember, we are trying to come together, not read faulty information that tends of tear us apart as a community.

11:56 PM  
Blogger orthomom said...

Go figure??? You like that phrase don't you?

Yep.

Get your facts and figures straight before you print lies that only tend to get your readers riled up for no reason.

Lies? Whoa. That's a mighty harsh accusation to make - especially when my "lies" are backed up with figures. You want to explain away the discrepancies between how many private school students vs. public school students qualify for services based on demographics? Feel free. But that doesn't make your argument "true" and mine "lies". It just makes for two differing takes on the huge discrepancy in numbers. The socioeconomic argument that has been suggested as a reason for the discrepancy is not an original one - we've heard it here many times. I just don't think it's enough. But hey, that's my opinion.

12:05 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Actually, the figures are closer to 7% for private school kids vs. 19% for public school kids, so OM may have been a bit off, but 3x is a fair approximation

12:07 AM  
Blogger orthomom said...

I back my figures up in the post I linked, but here is the relevant section:

The problem with that fact is that in reality, the district's public school students qualify for one of those state mandated services, Special Education, at a rate that is more than double that of private school students. And even that number is misleading in that district private school children further outnumber district public school children by 50%. So by extension, in reality children attending district public schools receive special ed at a rate of closer to three times that of district private schools.

12:11 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I just wanted to make a few observations on this topic. In my opinion, there are two main factors to show the possible reasons why there is a disproportionate percentage of kids receiving services.

The first reason is there is no magic percentage number to describe what a school or group will have in students receiving services. So when you compare anything, you have to include a decent flex in the percentage. You need to include at least a +/- 3% when comparing in a issue like this.

The second reason comes in when you compare different groups. Our school system, especially with a population going to private school is a largely diverse population of minority and low income families going to public schools and a largely homogenous population of middle class families going to private school. Social and economical issues can be the cause or lead to the cause of some of the classifications. This can also explain some of the percentage points differences between the private and public schools.

Finally, on a side note of this, what would the percentage be if both populations were together? Does it compare with the percentage of other school districts? If other schools percentages are closer to the private school percentage, will the tune of not receiving enough services change to public school students are receiving too many now? I only raise these questions because these number cannot always be compared purely mathematically without some side notes at the least.

3:13 AM  
Blogger NetureiKartanik said...

what services do charedi kinderlach get?

8:24 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

If you dont like it, send your kids to public schools!

2:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi, i was looking over your blog and didn't
quite find what I was looking for. I'm looking for
different ways to earn money... I did find this though...
a place where you can make some nice extra cash secret shopping.
I made over $900 last month having fun!
make extra money

12:07 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Maybe the reason parents do not want to send to public school has to do with this.

Father seeks answers in school bus incident
Posted by the Asbury Park Press on 08/1/06
BY RICHARD QUINN
TOMS RIVER BUREAU

LAKEWOOD — Chayim Kramer moved his 5-year-old son into the special education program at Oak Street School about a month ago with one caveat: Make sure he is kept safe.

Then, according to Kramer, the special-needs student escaped a school bus and needed to be chased down in the school's parking lot by three school district employees.

Now, Kramer wants the district to promise it will not happen again.

"Thankfully, nothing happened," said Kramer, who moved to Prospect Street from Brooklyn about five weeks ago. "I'm sending my son to school. I want him to come home."

District officials say they are reviewing the incident, which happened when the bus arrived at school July 24, to determine what safeguards might need to be put in place to ensure the safety of special education students.

Superintendent Edward W. Luick would make only general comments about the case, which Kramer made public at last week's Board of Education meeting.

"The district is responsible," Luick said. "We are dealing with it."

Board Attorney Michael Inzelbuch said the district will review how Kramer's situation was handled. Kramer said the answer to that is simple: not well.

Kramer said when he enrolled his son Shlomo, who he says is autistic, in a year-round program at Oak Street School, it was with a warning that the boy is a safety risk because he runs away at times.

Despite that warning, Kramer said, Shlomo got off the school bus alone on July 24.

"He's supposed to have a one-on-one aide who looks after him," Kramer said. "The aide wasn't there."

Kramer said he is not looking to punish the district. He just wants to make sure students are taken care of at all times.

"God forbid something happened," Kramer said.

Richard Quinn: (732) 557-5739 or rquinn@app.com

9:32 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have been looking for sites like this for a long time. Thank you! » »

7:42 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

That's a great story. Waiting for more. »

11:12 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very nice site! Portable+pc+projectors whirlpool refrigerator filter Kirby oldsmobile jeep Hunter tylo and plastic surgery

12:43 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

To be a upright charitable being is to be enduring a philanthropic of openness to the mankind, an gift to trusteeship unsure things beyond your own control, that can front you to be shattered in very exceptional circumstances on which you were not to blame. That says something exceedingly weighty with the get of the principled passion: that it is based on a corporation in the fitful and on a willingness to be exposed; it's based on being more like a spy than like a prize, something fairly fragile, but whose mere precise beauty is inseparable from that fragility.

2:14 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

n everyone's sustenance, at some time, our inner throw goes out. It is then blow up into zeal at near an encounter with another benign being. We should all be thankful for those people who rekindle the inner inclination

2:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Developing muscle tissue gear will continuously remind you to definitely physical exercise and do your operate out. [B][URL=http://www.fitnessworkoutclub.com/insanity-workout-dvds.html]insanity reviews[/URL][/B] today have personalized their products in accordance with costumer's convenience and pleasure. They've significantly recognize the individual [B][URL=http://www.fitnessworkoutclub.com]p90x workout[/URL][/B] and unique preference of the populace hence, [B]insanity reviews[/B] are offered the freedom of selection in terms of choosing the item that you simply think is probably the most appropriate to suit your needs. Maintaining a very good wellness maybe a trouble for some luckily, the most beneficial muscle tissue developing products [B][URL=http://www.fitnessworkoutclub.com]does p90x work[/URL][/B] available these days turn such problem into a sweet and delightful encounter.

[URL=http://www.fitnessworkoutclub.com][IMG]http://www.beachbody.com/images/en_US/products/programs/insanity/ins_sell_lloyd_a.jpg[/IMG][/URL]

4:28 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

[B][URL=http://www.thomassabosale.de]Thomas Sabo[/URL][/B] [B]Thomas Sabo onlineshop[/B] [U]Thomas Sabo charms[/U] [B]masai[/B] [U]swiss masai[/U] [B][URL=http://www.mbtschuheoutlet.de]mbt[/URL][/B]

[B]Thomas Sabo charms[/B] [B][URL=http://www.thomassabosale.de]Thomas Sabo charms[/URL][/B] [U]Thomas Sabo[/U] abercormbie fitch [B]mbt[/B] [B][URL=http://www.mbtschuheoutlet.de]masai barefoot[/URL][/B] [U]mbt[/U] vibram five fingers Performa [B]Thomas Sabo onlineshop[/B] [B][URL=http://www.salethomassabo.com]Thomas Sabo[/URL][/B] [U]Thomas Sabo charms[/U] mtb masai [B]vibram five fingers[/B] [B][URL=http://www.vibramfivefingersshop.de]fivefingers[/URL][/B] [U]vibram five fingers[/U] Thomas Sabo charms [B]abercormbie fitch[/B] [B][URL=http://www.abercrombieonsale.de]abercrombie[/URL][/B] [U]abercrombie and fitch[/U]

[B]abercrombie and fitch[/B] [U]abercormbie & fitch[/U] [B][URL=http://www.abercrombieonsale.de]abercrombie and fitch[/URL][/B] [B][URL=http://www.mbtschuheoutlet.de]mbt schuhe[/URL][/B] [B]mtb masai[/B] [U]masai footwear[/U] [B][URL=http://www.thomassabosale.de]Thomas Sabo schmuck[/URL][/B] [B]Thomas Sabo onlineshop[/B] [U]Thomas Sabo schmuck[/U] [B]mbt schuhe[/B] [U]mbt schuhe[/U] [B][URL=http://www.mbtschuheoutlet.de]mtb masai[/URL][/B]

9:23 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is hard to believe that anything [B][URL=http://www.mbtplus.com/]footwear etc[/URL][/B] so inherently ugly as the MBT shoe could ever catch on [U]mbt shoes sale[/U] with either the younger generation or the fitness fanatics but it has. [B]mbt shoes sale[/B] The shoes or I suppose they should be called trainers have thick curved soles and wide straps across the front. Currently [U][B]buy mbt shoes[/U][/B] the are available in over 20 countries and have sold more than a million pairs a year. Considering that they have a price tag of around $200 it is even [B]mbt sandals[/B] more remarkable.

MBT shoes, which stand for Masai [B]mbt shoes clearance[/B] Barefoot Technology were invented by Karl Muller a Swiss engineer. He [B]mbt sneakers[/B] suffered back and knee problems but on a trip to Korea he noticed [U][B]MBT shoes[/U][/B] that after walking barefoot through paddy fields the symptoms were relieved. With further [U]MBT shoes[/U] research he discovered that the Masai tribesmen from Kenya did not suffer back problems [B]mbt discount shoes[/B] and had perfect posture. Putting these two facts together he decided that [U]mbt walking shoes[/U] the answer was because they were walking on soft surfaces [U]mbt shoes review[/U] which yielded as they trod on them. This [U]mbt shoes cheap[/U] was unlike in Europe and America where we tend to walk on firm surfaces such as sidewalks.

The first MBT was manufactured in 1996 and soon [U][B]mbt shoes review[/U][/B] became popular on continental Europe. Since then many celebrities have [B]mbt sandals[/B] been seen sporting MBTs. The concept basically is that the [U][B]mbt sandals[/U][/B] curved sole creates instability as you walk, which [U][B]mbt shoes clearance[/U][/B] mimics the effect of walking barefoot. To counteract this the foot uses muscle to counter this [B][URL=http://www.mbtplus.com/]mbt walking shoes[/URL][/B] and creates a natural body training effect.


These are pretty bold claims but there is no doubt that MBT shoes are [U]mbt walking shoes[/U] popular both as recreation and sportswear. A study [U]mbt shoes review[/U] by Sheffield Hallam University recently concluded that MBT shoes were better for the knees ankles [U]buy mbt shoes[/U] than normal shoes. The study also concluded that if [U][B]mbt discount shoes[/U][/B] you walk correctly you would take shorter strides while walking in MBTs. Shorter [B]mbt shoes cheap[/B] strides would mean more steps and more expending of energy and this [U][B]MBT shoes[/U][/B] would increase your calorie burn.

12:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Trying to find an innovative and lucrative [B][URL=http://www.tiffanysfree.com]tiffany jewellery[/URL][/B] business? A business on sterling silver jewelries may just be the one you are [U][B]tiffany sets[/U][/B] looking for. It's never that too difficult to find reasonably priced Tiffany wholesale jewelry to get you [U][B]pandora jewellery[/U][/B] started on your way to being financially independent. The Internet is actually a good place [B]pandora beads[/B] to start. You virtually spend nothing to find the supplier you are seeking. No need to be technically knowledgeable to find [U]tiffany london][/U] your valuable information, a simple understanding of how to operate the computer and use a reliable search [B]tiffany uk[/B] engine is all you need.

Once you find your tiffany wholesale supplier, your quest [U][B]pandora bracelet[/U][/B] doesn't end there. You need to understand jewelry selling basics and selecting the styles that are most appropriate [B]tiffany engagement rings[/B] for your niche market as well as having the eye for designs that will [U]tiffany engagement rings][/U] most likely sell. You must also learn the tricks of finding out which jewelry pieces are [B]pandora beads[/B] of superior quality. There are an abundant source of suppliers for Tiffany wholesale jewelry, you just need [B][URL=http://www.pandoraforyou.com]pandora bracelets[/URL][/B] to have that discriminating taste in ensuring you get to the best source. In this business, if you start with low quality [U]tiffany][/U] pieces, your business will suffer.

The key to a profitable and lucrative business is to build a [U][B]pandora bracelet[/U][/B] large customer base. In order for you to get customers to comeback you must be [B][URL=http://www.tiffanysfree.com]tiffany charms[/URL][/B] able to please them with the quality of your items as well as the attractiveness of your designs. Always find unique [U][B]tiffany[/U][/B] and stylish designs, you wouldn't want to sell everybody else is selling. If your pieces are just ok and plain you may have difficulty [U][B]tiffany necklaces[/U][/B] keeping faithful customers. Aside from having quality merchandise you [U][B]pandora necklaces[/U][/B] also should be pricing them reasonably, not too expensive but not too cheap. Always make [B]tiffany london[/B] your customers feel special in finding the best priced jewelries they [U][B]tiffany bracelets[/U][/B] can find.

A good plan is definitely in order, plunging head on [U]tiffany necklaces][/U] into a business is like committing financial suicide. If you [B]pandora jewelry[/B] want your business to workout you need to sit down and make [U][B]tiffany jewellery[/U][/B] a list of what you need to do to achieve your main goal [U]tiffany sets][/U] of being the vendor of choice. A supplier of good quality Tiffany wholesale jewelries [U]tiffany jewellery][/U] should top the list, after all you shouldn't start any business if your [U][B]pandora[/U][/B] merchandise is not good at all.

8:48 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

As your conviction is strengthened you will-power declare that there is no longer the dire to from a sense of oversee, that things thinks fitting flow as they at one's desire, and that you drive course with them, to your great appreciate and benefit.

[url=http://petitelectromenager.eu]Cuiseurs à œufs[/url]
Cafetières à piston

8:48 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

A likeable beloved majority is the prize of a well-spent youth. A substitute alternatively of its bringing dejected and melancholy prospects of decay, it would sing us hopes of eternal youth in a recovered world.

8:26 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home