Anti-Semitic PSA on Indian Trains?
This story is just too weird:
A security sign on a train from Goa to Mumbai in India featured a written warning to passengers not to take eatables from strangers because they could be drugged and a drawing illustrating two religious Jews reading the Torah.Thoughts? Anyone ever seen a sign like on his/her travels?
"Never accept any eatables from a stranger or co-passenger whom you have never met before. They could be drugged," read security tip number 6, to the left of which appeared a diagram of two religious Jews.
posted by orthomom at 11:04 PM
27 Comments:
ok. weird doesnt begin to describe this story. were the jews in the cartoon supposed to be the druggers? the drugees? are they drugging each other?
Curious. I doubt it could exonorate but what was #5? The picture borders that point as well.
#5 is "Naisusle" it'a the Indian word for "Watch the Gap."
Honestly? The Indian graphic designer probably had no idea what the images were, but they certainly were STRANGE looking people. The point of the illustration was not to take food from strangers. No need for an Abe Foxman moment, IMHO.
Shmendrik makes a point, but I wouldn't rule out plain anti semitism.
Train is from Goa, a common post-army hangout for young Israelis.
I tend to agree with Shmendrik's "bad choice of clip art" thesis, but then, I tend to assume the best of people even when I shouldn't.
It looks like hamentashen in the drawing. Given some of the appalling hamentashen I've had over the years, maybe this is a fair warning. I never considered that I was being gifted with drugged hamentashen, but *something* has to account for all those rock-hard "eatables" that float around at Purim.
Now, if the drawing had featured the two Jews sharing a plate of Wacky Mac ... well, then train-riding Indians would have cause to be alarmed.
maybe the picture means "if you have unusual dietary taboos, and bump into someone who claims to have the same taboos, don't automatically trust them."
Perhaps the people in the picture are what the regular train riders usually look like (not the strangers)...and anyone who doesn't look like that is strange?
Maybe they were giving out free Wacky Mac?
if it was in an iranian. jordanian, or syrian train would you be surprised? what's so weird? india has one of the largest muslim populations (over 125M) in the world.
what's weird (really not weird, just surprising), is that apparently most people here dont know that much about one of the largest countries in the world.
A bad latke can ruin your day. I don't know, I don't get it.
India does not have a tradition of antisemitism, so I would be very surprised if there was any antisemitic intent. Probably just a bad choice of clip art.
Please don't jump to conclusions about our ignorance or lack thereof, Anon at 10:21. While I'm no expert in matters Indian, I am well aware of the religious makeup of the country.
Given some encouragement, I'm sure Indian Muslims would happily join their brethren in anti-Semitism, but so far, most Indian jihadists have focused instead on killing Hindus and Sikhs.
Also, the civil service employees responsible for creating this kind of sign or document are primarily Hindus. I don't harbor any illusions that Hindus are great friends to the Jews -- at least, they wouldn't be if they knew how we feel about avodah zorah! For right now, though, most seem to subscribe to the "enemy of my enemy" philosophy.
The key here is "stranger".
These Jews are probably the quintessential 'stranger' in that area, as the Israelis don't look anything like that.
Hamentashen? I thought it was a seder plate.
according to those in the know, Hinduism is probably not actually ‘avoda zara [for non-jews]. go search the archives of the Avodah listserv.
maybe they're telling the israelis not to accept food from chabadniks?
It is outright anti-semitism, and it is warning travelers to stay away from Jews. There have been an onslaught of anti-Israel (anti-Jewish) actions in India. Israelis have been warned to stop visiting there-danger to their lives.
This comment has been removed by the author.
@Pragmatician - I would respectfully disagree with you, and others that thought this imagine might have had any ill-will intended in it.
As a person that lived in India for over a year, I can say from experience that the country is filled with thousands of odd and incongruent tidbits like this, it's something you get used to.
Moreover, given that no Indian I encountered (aside from the Indian Jews I'd lived with in Bombay. Yes, there are Indian Jews.) had even heard of Judaism let alone ever seen an orthodox Jew in garb, I would conclude that this image was simply chosen for its 'strangeness' and portrayal of sharing food.
I would also take issue with prior comments that implied that given the demographic make-up of India (14% Muslim, I believe, in a population of 1.1 billion), it must automatically have anti-semitic viewpoints which an instance like this is representative of. It's simplistic comments/assumptions like these that feed into an 'us vs. them' mentality that has gotten us nowhere and is not in the spirit of the Jewish tradition, not to mention simply not being accurate.
I don't really get it. If we take the message literally, it says Jews could add marijuana to some food and feed the passenger. What for? Actually I think Israelis in India consume hashish and marijuana themselves, what's the point of giving marijuana to someone unknowing when you can share a joing with someone willing? Especially I don't get why some religious Jews are pictured, because drugs is what yongsters do, not grown-up and religious adults.
20150916 junda
Abercrombie and Fitch Outlet Sale
Coach Factory Outlet Online Sale
michael kors outlet
burberry outlet
michael kors handbags
coach factory outlet online
nfl jerseys
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors
michael kors handbags
hermes birkin bag
Abercrombie And Fitch Kids Online
tory burch outlet
ugg outlet store
Louis Vuitton Handbags Factory Store
celine
Louis Vuitton Handbags For Cheap
abercrombie
michael kors outlet
Michael Kors Outlet Real Handbags Online
hollister clothing store
Jordan 13 Shoes For Sale
Louis Vuitton Bags Outlet Store
louis vuitton
Louis Vuitton Luxury Official Website
coach factory outlet
Buy Kobe Shoes Online Discount
Jordan 6 Rings Powder Blue
ugg boots outlet
Michael Kors Online Outlet Shop
Coach Outlet Store Online Shop
Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Deals
Cheap Jordans For Sale Wholesale
ugg boots clearance
0616jejeralph lauren uk
kate spade
air jordan 8
bottega veneta
moncler online outlet
ralph lauren uk
mlb jerseys
ralph lauren outlet
golden goose shoes
pandora jewelry outlet
ray ban sunglasses
www0914
prada handbags
coach factory outlet
canada goose
red bottom shoes
nike outlet factory
coach outlet
true religion jeans
hermes belt
ralph lauren polo
mlb jerseys
yeezy shoes
adidas outlet
adidas shoes
coach outlet
coach outlet handbags
hermes belt
goyard bag sale
adidas nmd r1
goyard
adidas eqt
WWW1017
off white clothing
nike tn
moncler outlet
jordan 4
michael kors outlet
canada goose clothing
james harden shoes
pandora charms
converse trainer
kate spade outlet
hermes handbags
yeezy boost 350 v2
yeezy shoes
converse outlet
michael kors outlet online
nike air max 97
lebron 17
yeezy boost 350 v2
kyrie spongebob
kyrie shoes
Post a Comment
<< Home